Reconciling being pro-choice after recurrent pregnancy loss


Photo by Burst on Unsplash

I have a lot of feelings on this one.

I have long been very pro-choice — “virulently,” I’ve often joked. I don’t care or need to know what the reason is for a woman to choose termination; I don’t need to know how many weeks she is (especially since I’m well researched into the realities of what a third trimester abortion actually entails); I don’t need to know what she was or is like in her past, present or future.

But, as I’ve seen discussed in my loss groups and uttered by people unaffected by either loss or abortion, “How is one OK but not the other?”

In other words — if we say it’s okay to terminate an embryo or fetus at certain points because they are not yet living, why should miscarriage at those points mean anything?

To me? It all still boils down to that key word: choice.

After I had my first child, I remember being filled with rage and empathy for any woman ever forced to carry a pregnancy she didn’t want; to fulfill a birth she didn’t want. Agony for any woman who had never been given the choice in all of the eons of “we’re having sex for more than just procreation.” Pregnancy and labor are and can be debilitating. Life changing. My body is physically changed in ways that are negative; labor truly can be an excruciating process. And so on.

So with that being said, anyone who chooses to give an unwanted baby up for adoption: that’s amazing. But I don’t even remotely feel it should be the only option outside of “raising said unwanted child.” Women literally die during the processes of gestation and delivery. Frankly, I don’t see how forcing anyone through that who does not wish to be pregnant isn’t considered torture.

Going back to: choice.

You lose a lot of choice in pregnancy. I have spoken at lengths with other people about this and have read more pieces than I can count on it. The moment a woman gets pregnant, she ceases to be seen as someone who can make choices for herself: all choices must be made in the lens of baby. Vaginal or Cesarean? Lunchmeat or no lunchmeat? To work alongside parenting or not? Do I dare sleep on my back or no?

Here’s the thing that sticks with me through both my pro-choice stance and also the reality that I am forever impacted by my many miscarriages: I didn’t have a choice.

That same choice I want women to have to choose to get pregnant or not, and subsequently choose to keep a pregnancy or not, I feel carries through to pregnancy loss. I wanted those babies; I did not get a choice to keep them and it destroyed me. Women who did not want babies and did not get a choice to terminate can feel destroyed, too.

Now what of the comments that occur? The justifications some pro-choicers make?

“It was just a bunch of cells.”

To an extent, yes, this is true. I see those 6 week abortion bans try to get passed in the states and I feel chills. A six week ultrasound doesn’t even always show a heartbeat — sometimes you’re still waiting to see a fetal pole. It is, more or less, a chocolate chip size bundle of cells.

But in the same way I don’t think women should be penalized for wanting to terminate a “potential baby,” I can be sad about the loss of a “potential baby.”

What about later? In many places throughout the world, termination is allowed up to 20 weeks, and sometimes even up until “viability” (23 to 24 weeks) without requiring certain legal and medical hurtles. Those are more than a clump of cells.

But it also remains — where is the choice here for either party? I can be sad that I passed the sac of my future baby at home after contractions and sobbing; I can support a woman who took a pill and went home to do the same because she did not want the baby. Her choice does not invalidate my choice to be sad. She didn’t take my baby away from me (an unfortunate sentiment I often seen uttered by women with RPL who are anti-choice).

And the real nitty gritty is that many of us have shared the exact same steps: missed miscarriages often get the same treatment as a voluntary termination. Taking a pill and waiting, or going in for a D&C surgery.

Our losses are both even dubbed the same thing: abortions. Those of who miscarry just get the “spontaneous” part in front.

As for the late term abortions? My world was forever shaken when I read a piece by a woman who was so grateful for the ability to choose this for her fetus with a terminal diagnosis. Without the option for “early induction” (often code for late term abortion when it’s for a terminal fetus), she would have had to wait until her baby died inside her before seeing him, since he was certainly going to die. Instead, she was able to hold him alive for those precious seconds following the late term abortion since his death was inevitable. The legal ability to choose termination gave her the life of her son. She got to experience those last breaths.

What about the flipside of all of this — the people who discount pregnancy loss? The “it wasn’t a real baby” comments? Well, if you are simultaneously pro-life when saying this, I have a phrase in mind for you that isn’t pleasant (and I’ve absolutely encountered anti-choicers who didn’t give a damn about miscarriages to those close to them). If you are pro-choice and feel the same way, I ask only that you reflect on that “choice” as well; me seeing these losses as my babies, especially the ones where we knew the sex and what they died of (or never got a chance to survive with), does not mean we need to reevaluate terminations elsewhere. Quote me in your arguments with anti-choicers, too: I am a woman who has had 8 miscarriages and is still very pro-choice.

And in light of that revelation, too — yes, we know our losses were unviable. After agonizing (and expensive) testing and waiting and miscarriages, wondering if I was aborting healthy babies myself by not having enough thyroid hormone or any other issue that we hypothesized, we learned that we were losing aneuploid embryos and fetuses. An unlucky combo of bad sperm and a very receptive uterus.

The other phrases I hear often on this topic include: well, there was something wrong with them. It’s good they never made it to term. They weren’t going to survive anyway. Did you really want to bring an unhealthy baby into the world?

Well, I didn’t get a choice on that last one. But I can tell you, as somehow who fully always planned to terminate for medical reasons if ever faced with that horrendous dilemma, that I was fully versed in the rare trisomies we kept making because I was ready to try and bring one to term. I so wanted another baby. And I was so, so tired of losing them. But I get why anyone would choose to terminate. And I also get why someone might wait to let the fetus die within them, too. Even not choosing to do anything is, after all, still a choice.

And let’s not forget: rarely do miscarriages and loss get any focus. Don’t talk to me of saving unborn babies if you don’t even ask when mine were due, what their names were, or how I felt when I lost them.

If you protest outside of a clinic but have never even sent a card to someone after a loss, you’re a hypocrite.

If you devote your life to “saving unborn babies” but you don’t consider me a mother of 11, you’re a hypocrite.

If you have no problem not minding your own business about other women’s bodies by being “pro-life,” but don’t inquire into how a loss mom is doing or how she felt about her baby because it’s “not my business,” you’re a hypocrite.

If you donate to politicians and organizations based on the premise of “pro-life” but have never given a dime to the same bent on researching pregnancy and infant loss…

Shame on you.


2 thoughts on “Reconciling being pro-choice after recurrent pregnancy loss

  1. Eryn says:

    I am struggling so badly right now, but there is no one else. No one I know, is like you.

    So that said, I am going to overshare here, like I’ve never done before in a comments section. Because I’ve been reading your words in various places and you may be the only person to understand any of this…

    I am currently writing this while still in the thoes of my third miscarriage. I too have thyroid issues. And I gave birth to a beautiful son with no trouble. And then the losses came, and the pain and unbridled heartache. I too have the husband with suppressed feelings as those losses began outnumbering us. And I heave and grasp for connection in my loss, but we just don’t grieve the same way. I have turned my life upside down and backwards with lifestyle changes. Gluten-free, soy-free, dairy free, sugar, egg, nightshades… And I still have my son’s baby clothes because I can’t tell if saving them is jinxing us or if throwing them away would be the final nail in a coffin I refuse to close. I noted your feelings on it are the former but I just… I can’t… yet.

    All that said, you… you just get it. Like no one else does. I am teaching myself about hyper-fertility now… which is how I found you. Cause why else would my 69 chromosome triploid baby (my second baby) have survived that long? When by all accounts I shouldn’t have even seen a positive test, let alone made it to my eight-week ultrasound? What else would explain the ease of getting pregnant four times and ending up here. Again.

    I just agree with every sentiment. Every word you’ve written on loss. And I know, this is a weird place to leave these comments, under a post about reconciling my pro-choice feelings and my losses. But even with this topic, you’ve given a voice to something I’ve felt but may have ever so briefly faltered in (as I did need to reconcile the two). And you’ve done so with an eloquence and an appreciation that recognizes that no one can ever know how another person’s shoes feel.

    I wish I could ask you all sort of questions, cause I still have many stones unturned at this point. But I’m a stranger on the internet and I recognize that’s not how this works.

    So, I instead I will just thank you.
    Thank you for this post and all the rest.

    • Eryn,

      Thank you so much for sharing with me. I have read your comment multiple times and wanted to have time to sit down and fully respond to you, because my heart aches with knowing what you’re going through. And it is all consuming, devastating.

      And thank you so much for letting me know my words meant something to you. I can only hope it’s helped to have someone to relate to, because it’s such a lonely place to be. The infertility world doesn’t really belong to us, because we almost grow to dread “BFPs” out of fear and anxiety because we get pregnant so easily, whereas those members are in a whole different place. And then even in the “miscarriage” world, you find women with one or two losses before success, and that feels just as foreign. The recurrent loss world becomes even smaller, and I found so many women who would find the answers to their losses… but then you get women like us.

      I can say, that I am (fingers crossed) on the other side with a working theory for why we had our losses. If you are ever in need of more questions or a place to vent, please, please don’t hesitate to email me (shelbyilene @ gmail . com) or Tweet/DM me on Twitter (@RagingBanshee), the only places I really frequent social media wise.

      Your words spoke to me just as much as mine seemed to speak to you. It’s a bully thing to be kindred spirits over, but I am here. I hope I will hear from you — and hopefully will be rejoicing with you finding success soon.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s